Menu of Miller's Creamery in New Philadelphia, Ohio, USA

Menu Overview

Miller's Creamery, located at 2337 E High Ave in New Philadelphia, Ohio, is a cherished ice cream shop that stands out not only for its classic treats but also for its diverse and thoughtfully curated menu. Visiting this local gem felt like stepping into a place where tradition meets creativity, a spot that clearly resonates deeply with the community. Their Vanilla Soft Serve exemplifies simplicity done right—smooth, creamy, and perfectly balanced, it’s the foundation that sets the tone for the rest of their offerings.

One highlight that deserves special mention is the Blueberry Doughnut Ice Cream Sandwich. This inventive combination perfectly marries sweet bakery flair with rich, fruity ice cream, creating an indulgence that is both nostalgic and refreshingly unique. The Coconut Sherbet is another standout, offering a dairy-free option that’s light yet flavorful, ideal for those seeking a tropical respite that’s not overly sweet. Their Ice Cream Cone varieties make for perfect single-serving treats, allowing customers to indulge in classic flavors like Mint, Cherry, and Caramel, each crafted with care and attention to taste.

Miller's Creamery doesn’t stop at ice cream. Their mini menu features slushes, shakes, and the intriguingly named Stormin Normans, adding variety and fun to the experience. The presence of a Doggie Sundae on their sundae menu reflects a warm, community-focused spirit, inviting pets to join in the fun. Beyond desserts, Miller’s offers a broader food selection including burgers, hot dogs, and sandwiches—a fact well noted by patrons like Hailey Jones, who praised the hefty double cheeseburgers and comforting homemade soups such as Zuppa Toscana. This versatility makes the Creamery more than just an ice cream stop; it's a full-flavored destination.

What truly elevates the Miller's experience is their attentive and friendly staff. Reviewers like Kirstin Lemasters highlight the genuine kindness of the team and management, which enhances customer satisfaction. The willingness to accommodate substitutions and quickly address concerns—such as swapping out stale chips—speaks to a customer-centric ethos that builds trust and loyalty.

Equally impressive is the efficiency reflected in the drive-thru service, noted for its speed and accuracy despite being staffed primarily by high school workers. The commitment to quality extends to dietary accommodations, with dairy-free options thoughtfully provided, ensuring accessibility and comfort for all guests.

Additionally, the Creamery’s side offerings—home-baked cakes, cookies, popcorn, and branded apparel like shirts and hoodies—turn a simple ice cream visit into a memorable outing with souvenirs to take home. The ample and welcoming seating inside allows for a relaxed atmosphere, perfect for enjoying anything from a classic Banana Split to a rich Brownie Batter Shake.

In sum, Miller's Creamery is more than a traditional ice cream parlor; it’s a community hub that celebrates flavor, variety, and warmth. Whether you come for a creamy vanilla cone or a full meal with a handcrafted shake, you’re met with quality, care, and a touch of local charm that makes every visit a treat worth savoring.