Millers Creamery | A Delicious Ice Cream Destination in New Philadelphia, OH

Overview

Located at 2337 E High Ave in New Philadelphia, Ohio, Miller's Creamery stands out as a charming ice cream shop that doubles as a local food hub. It’s the kind of place where the joy of classic soft serve meets the warmth of homemade treats and comforting diner-style fare. The atmosphere invites families, friends, and ice cream lovers alike to indulge in a variety of flavors and freshly made dishes.

Their vanilla soft serve is a quintessential delight—smooth, creamy, and perfectly balanced. Yet, Miller’s doesn’t stop there. Unique offerings like the Blueberry Doughnut Ice Cream Sandwich and the Coconut Sherbet show their dedication to creative, refreshing twists on frozen favorites. For sundae lovers, the Doggie Sundae adds a playful touch for pet owners seeking a treat for their furry friends.

Beyond ice cream, the menu surprises with hearty options such as massive double cheeseburgers, sloppy joes, and chili cheese dogs that pair well with their house specialties. Customers appreciate the homemade soups—like the praised Zuppa Toscana—adding a savory counterpoint to the sweet ice cream experience. The inclusion of familiar comfort foods alongside a well-curated drink selection, including root beers and coffee latte shakes, creates a well-rounded dining experience.

The vibe inside is relaxed and spacious, with plenty of seating that makes it an inviting spot for both quick stops and leisurely visits. The staff stands out for their friendliness and attentiveness, ensuring seamless service whether at the drive-thru or inside. Manager Madison’s personal touch and willingness to accommodate special requests contribute to a welcoming, community-focused environment.

Miller’s Creamery also honors regional tastes through its homemade ice cream cakes like Ohio Buckeye and Peanut Butter Cup, perfect for celebrations. For those mindful of dietary needs, they thoughtfully offer dairy-free options, garnering appreciation from customers seeking inclusivity without sacrificing flavor.

Ideal for locals and visitors craving comfort food with an ice cream twist, Miller’s Creamery captures the essence of a small-town favorite. It is a place where tradition meets creativity, delivering consistently delightful treats in a friendly, unpretentious setting. Whether you visit for a cone, a cake, or a satisfying sandwich, Miller’s promises a memorable experience every time.

Menu Highlights

See Full Menu

Amenities & Services

Popular for

Solo dining

Offerings

Coffee

Atmosphere

Casual

Trending

Trendy

What Customers Say

Brad Mayfield

Dec 3,2025

5/5

A local staple, and for a reason! Always a 10/10, such a treat.

Hailey Jones

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Adorable place with a bigger menu than I expected. There's burgers, hot dogs, sandwiches, soups, and daily specials in addition to their large ice cream menu. They don't do fries but they have name brand chips, homemade soup, and canned soda. The double cheeseburgers are massive and cheesey! I also loved my zuppa toscana soup and coffee latte shake. Chilli on the hotdog is on the sweet side, but still enjoyable. There's no sign out front of the building, looks like they're at the end of a big remodel, but definitely recommend stopping and trying. Plenty of seating on the inside and they had ice cream, cakes, cookies, popcorn, shirts, and hoodies for sale to take home too.

Kirstin Lemasters

Dec 3,2025

4/5

Stopped by Miller’s Creamery while in town. Overall, it was a good experience. I had the sloppy joe, which was really sweet, but I actually like it that way. I added mustard and it hit the spot. The brownie batter shake was the standout. So rich and delicious. The staff was friendly. They swapped out my stale chips without any hassle, and they made a one-time exception for my grandma to trade her slushee for a shake, which we appreciated. Madison, the manager, was especially kind and helpful. If I had one suggestion, it would be to let customers substitute a cheaper item for a more expensive one on the specials. For example, letting someone pick a slushee instead of a shake without an issue. That little change could make things even better.

Sarah Cecil

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Went through the drive thru, surprisingly fast and orders came out perfectly. Very nice staff of high school kids who had it under control and clean and efficient. Also HUGE kudos for having dairy free options. Saved my guts

Arlen Miller

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Most delightful sherbet in quarts and other ice cream goodies. Delightful place. Lots of open seating.

MED

Dec 3,2025

5/5

One of my favourite central Ohio ice cream stops - plenty of flavors & mixes - kind of out-of-the-way but easy to drive to - primary store in on main drag in Millersburg, Ohio & it is better, with more old fashioned charm

Jennifer Hines

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Friendly and helpful staff...Plenty of hand dipped Ice cream offerings and also soft serve available. A large sandwiches/sides menu .. It's all priced reasonably. For an ice cream business, it's extremely clean !! .. Large dine in area and of course very family friendly.. and for those those in a hurry, I hear that their drive thru is very quick and accurate !! ..On a busy Friday night dine in .. From the time we placed our order , we enjoyed our ice cream treat. we were back on the road in 25 minutes. .. I ordered a hot fudge sundae with no toppings, although they had plenty of toppings to choose from. Apple crisp, picked by my brother and pumpkin ice cream for my sister.. welcome to Fall .

Keith Stoneman

Dec 3,2025

4/5

First time customer. Double cheeseburger and coney were great. A little bummed French fries aren't available. Fountain drinks would be a great addition over cans of pop. I'll be back to try the ice cream. Wife thought the banana split was very good.